Manchester United's Interest in Baleba Persists Despite Struggles

Carlos Baleba's Brighton future uncertain as United circles

Carlos Baleba's future at Brighton uncertain as Manchester United remains interested in £100m midfielder.

“In the end, it’s a bad decision from the referee to give him...”

Carlos Baleba's future at Brighton & Hove Albion is uncertain, with Manchester United reportedly circling for the midfielder. Despite his current struggles, Baleba's valuation remains at £100 million, according to Brighton.

The 22-year-old Cameroonian has attracted interest from several top clubs, including Chelsea, Tottenham, and Paris Saint-Germain, but United is considered his preferred destination. However, Brighton's stance is clear: they won't entertain offers below £100 million, and some reports suggest they might accept around £75 million.

Baleba's form has dipped this season, with only four accurate passes in his last game, raising concerns about his value. United's interest might be rekindled if Brighton reduces their asking price, but for now, the Seagulls are holding firm.

Manchester United's interest in Carlos Baleba remains, but the midfielder's form and status at Brighton are uncertain. His struggles were laid bare in midweek, when he was substituted after just 22 minutes against Aston Villa.

Baleba looked distraught in the dugout after being withdrawn so early, highlighting the difficulties he faces.

Baleba's season has been stop-start, with just two Premier League games completed. His latest substitution against Aston Villa raised eyebrows, but Brighton boss Fabian Hurzeler explained the decision was tactical.

Hurzeler said Baleba received an early yellow and, with the game opening up, there were concerns he'd risk a red card. The coach moved to protect his player, prioritizing caution over risking a second booking.

“We've already spoken,” Hurzeler said. “In the end, it’s a bad decision from the referee to give him, in this situation, a yellow card.

“It’s a wrong decision for me. I saw a lot of similar fouls afterwards without giving yellow cards so it doesn't make sense for me.”

An early change sees James Milner replace Carlos, who was booked after two minutes. ⏱️ pic.twitter.com/4PFhoKTmPB

— Brighton & Hove Albion (@OfficialBHAFC) February 11, 2026

Baleba's Form Struggle Continues

Fabian Hurzeler framed Baleba's substitution as protection, not punishment, citing an early yellow card and concerns about a potential red. This isn't the first time Baleba's been taken off after being booked this season, highlighting his struggles to reset and recapture his best form.

Baleba's early exit against Aston Villa is another example of his season being disrupted, with just two Premier League games completed. 

Some think Carlos Baleba's struggles stem from Manchester United's strong interest last year, possibly distracting him. United's pursuit might've had a lingering impact, affecting his form and focus at Brighton.

What's intriguing is United's interest hasn't faded. Despite Baleba's struggles, they're still circling, adding complexity to his situation at Brighton. 

Manchester United still admires Baleba, sources indicate. However, Brighton's £100m valuation makes a move unlikely. United's interest might resurface if the price drops closer to £70m, making him a more feasible target.

Baleba's current struggles and Brighton's asking price create a stalemate. 

Baleba's situation is complicated by United's widening midfield search. He's now one of several options, alongside Elliot Anderson (Nottingham Forest), Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace), Sandro Tonali (Newcastle), and Joao Gomes (Wolves).

With multiple targets in the mix, Baleba's £100m valuation might not be enough to secure a move. He's at a pivotal point, and how he handles this moment will impact his future.