Jamie Carragher Questions Jadon Sancho's Ability After Villa Loan

Jadon Sancho

Jamie Carragher questions Jadon Sancho's ability after his loan move to Aston Villa. Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher doubts Jadon Sancho's quality.

“I’m still not sure there’s that much ability there. He’s okay, but I don’t really see what his standout quality is...”

Jamie Carragher, former Liverpool defender, has questioned Jadon Sancho's ability after his loan move to Aston Villa. Carragher believes Sancho lacks a standout quality compared to other top wingers, stating, “I'm still not sure there's that much ability there. He's okay, but I don't really see what his standout quality is.”

Concerns about Sancho's Game

Lack of Pace: Paul Scholes, Manchester United legend, shares Carragher's concerns, suggesting Sancho's lack of pace could be an issue for him at Villa Park.

Uncertainty about Strengths: Carragher can't pinpoint Sancho's strengths, wondering if he can cut inside and smash the ball into the top corner or beat a man.

Comparison to Rashford: Carragher contrasts Sancho with Marcus Rashford, saying he can picture Rashford's pace, shooting, and free kicks, but can't picture Sancho's standout quality.

Jadon Sancho. pic.twitter.com/01MmF1EsMm

— Aston Villa (@AVFCOfficial) September 1, 2025

Sancho's move to Aston Villa comes after a turbulent spell at Manchester United, where he scored just 12 goals in 83 appearances since joining from Borussia Dortmund in a £73 million deal in 2021. His loan move to Aston Villa might be an opportunity for him to revive his career.

Jadon Sancho's career hasn't quite taken off as expected. After spending the second half of the 2023/24 season on loan at Borussia Dortmund, he joined Chelsea last summer. However, Chelsea decided not to make the deal permanent, opting to pay a £5 million penalty fee instead. Sancho's struggles continued, prompting him to join Aston Villa on a season-long loan in a bid to revive his career.

Former Liverpool star Jamie Carragher has questioned Sancho's quality, stating he doesn't see a “standout quality” in the winger. Carragher recalled a past instance where he and Gary Neville left Sancho out of an England squad, sparking criticism on social media. Despite Sancho's impressive reputation at Dortmund, Carragher believes his abilities don't live up to the hype.

Paul Scholes also expressed doubts about Sancho's signing, calling it a “weird” move due to Sancho's lack of pace, which might be a concern at Villa Park. Despite these concerns, Sancho will look to prove himself at Aston Villa, potentially making his debut against Everton.

“It’s funny with Jadon Sancho. Back when he was at Borussia Dortmund, Gary Neville and I were on a show where we had to pick an England squad.  

“We hadn’t seen too much of him – he was doing well in the Champions League, but we left him out. Everyone on social media was saying, ‘How can you not pick Sancho?’ 

“I’m still not sure there’s that much ability there. He’s okay, but I don’t really see what his standout quality is.  

“With Marcus Rashford, even though I’ve criticised him, I can picture his pace, his shooting, his free kicks, the power he puts into the ball. With Sancho, I just don’t know what his thing is – I can’t picture it in my head.”

Jadon Sancho's journey at Manchester United has been quite a rollercoaster. Since joining the club from Borussia Dortmund in a £73 million deal in 2021, he's managed just 12 goals in 83 appearances. After a tumultuous spell at Old Trafford, Sancho has joined Aston Villa on a season-long loan deal.

Sancho's likely to make his Villa debut against Everton on September 14, rather than this Saturday, September 9, as Aston Villa's manager Unai Emery might opt for a more familiar lineup initially. The winger's had a tough time finding consistency, and his last outings haven't exactly been stellar. Still, with his pace, creativity, and flair on the ball, Sancho's expected to bring a dynamic edge to Villa's attacking lineup.

Sancho's Stats:

• Appearances for Manchester United: 83
• Goals scored: 12
• Transfer fee: £73 million
• Previous clubs: Borussia Dortmund, Chelsea (on loan)

Sancho's move to Aston Villa comes after a loan spell at Chelsea, where he scored 5 goals in 41 appearances. With Harvey Elliott also joining Villa on loan from Liverpool, the team might have some exciting attacking options.