Shearer Slams Isak's Approach: Newcastle Transfer Talks Hit Roadblock

Alexander Isak wants out

Alan Shearer criticizes Alexander Isak's approach to transfer talks with Newcastle United. Read the latest on the transfer saga and its implications.

“Everything sort of boils down to: I think he's being given bad advice and the way he's going about it is...”

Alan Shearer's Take on Alexander Isak-Newcastle Impasse

Newcastle United legend Alan Shearer believes the ongoing impasse between Alexander Isak and the club is detrimental to both parties. According to Shearer, Isak's approach to resolving the situation has been misguided, and he should reevaluate his agent's role in the negotiations. Shearer thinks Isak still has the potential to play for Newcastle again, but the current situation is an “absolute mess.”

The Transfer Saga

Isak recently expressed his desire to leave Newcastle United, citing broken promises and lost trust. Liverpool's reported £110 million bid for the Sweden international was rejected by Newcastle, which is holding out for a British transfer record fee of up to £150 million. Shearer suggests that Isak's agent, Vlado Lemic, has failed to provide adequate advice, leading to the current stalemate.

Potential Consequences

If Isak and Newcastle United fail to resolve their differences, it could lead to a prolonged transfer saga, potentially impacting both parties. Shearer advises Isak to reconsider his approach and prioritize finding a solution that benefits everyone involved.

 

🚨⚠️ BREAKING! Alexander Isak releases statement: “When promises are broken and trust is lost, the relationship can't continue”.

“I'm proud to be recognised by my fellow professionals with a place in the PFA Premier League Team of the Season for 2024/25.

First and foremost I… pic.twitter.com/hLr9xGUsLk

— Fabrizio Romano (@FabrizioRomano) August 19, 2025

Newcastle United has firmly denied any commitment to sell Alexander Isak, emphasizing that the 25-year-old striker remains a key part of their long-term project. Despite Liverpool's £110 million offer being rejected, Newcastle values Isak at £150 million and intends to build their squad around him. Isak's contract extension until 2028 further solidifies his importance to the team.

Isak, who has scored 62 goals in all competitions since joining Newcastle United for a club-record fee in 2022, has been training separately from the rest of the squad. He missed the team's goalless draw with Aston Villa in their Premier League opener on Saturday, fueling speculation about his future at the club. Isak's current situation stems from broken promises and lost trust, leading him to express his desire to leave the club.

Key Developments:

• Contract Extension: Isak signed a 3-year contract extension with Newcastle United in June 2025, securing his future at St. James' Park until 2028.

• Transfer Speculation: Liverpool's rejected bid and Isak's public statement have intensified transfer rumors, with potential compensation of £50-60 million if Isak leaves via Article 17.

• Current Status: Isak remains under contract with Newcastle United, but his strained relationship with the club may impact his future performances.

Alexander Isak's Statement on His Future

Alexander Isak has publicly expressed his desire to leave Newcastle United, citing broken promises and lost trust as the reason for his decision. 

Isak's Recent Recognition

Despite the ongoing transfer saga, Isak was named in the PFA Premier League Team of the 2024/25 season, a testament to his impressive performances on the pitch. However, he chose not to attend the ceremony due to the uncertainty surrounding his future at Newcastle United. Isak's situation continues to unfold, with his relationship with the club appearing increasingly strained.

Newcastle United statement: Alexander Isak

— Newcastle United (@NUFC) August 19, 2025

Potential Next Steps

Isak's future at Newcastle United remains uncertain, with the player seemingly determined to move on from the club. The potential for a transfer to Liverpool or another top club is still on the table, but negotiations between Isak and Newcastle United will be crucial in determining his next move.

“When promises are broken and trust is lost, the relationship can't continue,” Isak wrote on Instagram stories.

This statement comes after Liverpool's reported £110 million bid for the Sweden international was rejected by Newcastle United.

He continued, “change is in the best interests of everyone, not just myself.

“I've kept quiet for a long time while others have spoken. This silence has allowed people to perpetuate their own version of events, even though they know it doesn't reflect what was really said and agreed behind closed doors.

“The reality is that promises were made, and the club has known my position for a long time. Acting as if these issues have only just emerged is misleading.”

Newcastle were quick to respond.

“We are clear in response that Alex remains under contract,” the club said.

“We want to keep our best players, but we also understand players have their own wishes, and we listen to their views.

“As explained to Alex and his representatives, we must always take into consideration the best interests of Newcastle United, the team and our supporters in all decisions, and we have been clear that the conditions of a sale this summer have not transpired. We do not foresee those conditions being met.”

Shearer said while there was still the potential for Isak to play again for Newcastle, he had gone about things the wrong way and should question his agent's role.

“Everything sort of boils down to: I think he's being given bad advice and the way he's going about it is wrong,” Shearer said.

“It's not a good look on a player or an agent to not go out and train and not go out and play when you have a contract behind you.”